About Us

Greg Nicholas

– Owner/Agent

With more than three decades of experience in the insurance industry, Greg Nicholas is the proud owner of Nicholas Insurance in York, PA. Greg has built his agency on the values of trust, service, and community commitment, ensuring that every client receives personalized coverage and guidance tailored to their needs.

Professional Recognition

Greg’s career is marked by a long list of awards and honors recognizing his dedication to excellence and client service, including

• Allstate Premier Service Agency
• Premier Financial Professional
• Quality Agent (five years)
• Honor Ring (twenty-five years)
• National Conference Award (twenty-five years)
• Chairman’s Inner Circle (three years)
• Allstate Financial Leader Award (thirteen years)
• National Advisory Board (three years)

These accolades reflect Greg’s consistent commitment to professionalism and his reputation as a trusted insurance advisor.

Industry Involvement

Greg is actively engaged in advancing the insurance profession through his involvement in key organizations, including:

• National Association of Life Underwriters
• Pennsylvania Chamber of Commerce
• York Chamber of Commerce
• York Business Exchange

Community Service

Beyond his professional accomplishments, Greg is deeply committed to giving back to the York community. He is a financial supporter of Human Life Services and the Christian School of York, as well as a proud board member of Olivia’s House Children’s Center, an organization that provides support to grieving children and families.

A Trusted Partner in Insurance

Greg’s dedication to his clients, his profession, and his community defines
Nicholas Insurance as more than just an agency—it’s a partner you can count on
for trusted coverage and compassionate service.

Pennie Troutman

– Licensed Insurance Specialist

Hi! My name is Pennie and I’m a licensed insurance agent who truly enjoyshelping people feel confident and protected when it comes to life’s “what ifs.” I take the time to get to know each client so I can recommend coverage that actually fits their needs—not just a one-size-fits-all policy. Whether you’re buying your first home, car, or just wanting to make sure your family is secure, my goal is to make insurance simple, stress-free, and easy to understand. I believe in being approachable, reliable, and always just a phone call away when you need me. I believe in working hard, staying curious, and always finding reasons to laugh and have fun along the way. In my free time I enjoy traveling, spending time with friends and family and working on home renovation projects with my husband. I’m passionate about growth, connection, and making a diHerence in both big and small ways. I am licensed in PA and MD, you can contact me today with any questions you may have.

Alexis Miller

– Licensed Insurance Specialist

Hi, I’m Alexis! I’ve been working in Insurance for about a year and a half, and I specialize in helping people find the right coverage for their home and auto needs. My goal is to make insurance feel simple and stress-free, while making sure you feel confident that the things you care about are protected. I believe in building real connections with my clients, so you’ll always get honest guidance and reliable protection tailored to your needs. I take the time to really understand what matters most to each client, so the coverage we choose fits your life and is not just a policy on paper. Outside of work, you’ll usually find me spending time with friends, driving and exploring new places, or I’m spending time with my cat relaxing at home.

Justin Livelsberger

– Licensed Insurance Specialist

I’m a licensed insurance agent committed to helping my clients protect what matters most. I take a personalized approach to insurance, making sure individuals and families find the right coverage for their unique needs while building long-term peace of mind. My goal is to make insurance simple and transparent without confusing jargon and without a high-pressure approach. When I am not working with my clients, you’ll usually find me spending time with my dog Ollie, and enjoying the simple moments in life.